Is your interview style scaring away the best candidates?

If any of the following styles ring a bell, it might be time to change tactics.
It’s no secret. If you want the best, you have to interview like the best.
This is why your interview technique can be the make-or-break factor in securing top talent.
So, we’ve listed four common errors that could cause those perfect candidates to walk straight back out the door.
1. A lukewarm welcome
Imagine stepping into an office where no one expects you or makes you feel welcome.
Likely, you’d start questioning what you’re stepping into, right?
First impressions matter! Treat candidates as you would a valued client: greet them by name and make them feel important.
2. Sorry, did you want to say something?
Remember, it’s not an interrogation. Not letting them ask questions or ignoring answers clouds your judgement on a candidate’s suitability and suggests disinterest.
They’re assessing you as much as you are them. Ensure it’s a two-way conversation!
3. Dimming your own lights
The best candidates are drawn to the best companies. They want to know why you work there, so highlight team members’ success stories and show passion for the company and its values.
If you’re negative or vague about the company’s merits, you’ll raise major red flags.
4. Ghosting candidates
The post-interview phase is as critical as the interview itself.
Leaving candidates in the dark is agonising for them and harms your reputation. Make sure you set clear expectations for the follow-up and stick to them.
It’s more important than you think!
In all honesty, we know interviewing can be tricky. If you need help or advice, get in touch!
Consult Recruitment
Recent Posts
Retention in 2026: What actually keeps people engaged?
Celebrating B Corp Month at Consult
Fix in ‘26 – Economic Outlook Insights with Jarrod Kerr,…
Ultimate jobseeker guides
End of 2025 Market Update
Leading people in an AI world – AI & Leadership…
Celebrating New Zealand’s 2025 Best Places to Work
Finding roles in the hidden job market
Blog categories
Our latest blog posts.

Retention in 2026: What actually keeps people engaged?
Our recent Summer 2026 What the Buck? market survey shows professionals are feeling more confident than last year. That doesn’t

Celebrating B Corp Month at Consult
March is B Corp Month and for us at Consult, that means celebrating being two years into our B Corp

Fix in ‘26 – Economic Outlook Insights with Jarrod Kerr, Kiwibank Chief Economist
This article was published with our partners, LEAD Executive Search. It’s always great to have Jarrod back in our office
Hiring or job hunting? You’ll want this.
Get our latest What the Buck? Market Snapshot & Salary Report.
What the Buck? is proprietary research we run once a year. It’s fresh, NZ-specific and built to help businesses and professionals understand the job market and make better hiring and career decisions.